Thursday, April 29, 2010

Quote #5

In chapter 17 of The Scarlet Letter, Hester and Dimmesdale finally get to escape the town and sit hand in hand by a secluded brook. Hester breaks the news that Chillingworth is really her husband and Dimmesdale becomes furious with her. In the end, Dimmesdale forgives Hester and realizes that Chillingworth is a worse sinner then the both of them. He says, “We are not, Hester, the worst sinners in the world. There is one worse than even the polluted priest! That old man’s revenge has been blacker than my sin.” Even though what Hester and Dimmesdale did was horrible, Chillingworth is more of a sinner than them both and is truly a depiction of the devil.

At first, what Hester did seemed horrible and you would think it would have hurt her husband so badly. However, Chillingworth seemed like he could of cared less. The only thing he wanted was to get back at whoever committed adultery with Hester. Not caring and having revenge the only thing on his mind shows his poor character. He did everything in his power to torture Dimmesdale just like the devil would torture someone for his or her own satisfaction.

This quote tells how Dimmesdale feels about his own sin and about Chillingworth. He knows what he and Hester did was bad, but he believes that what Chillingworth is doing to him is worse. Most people who read this book think that Hester and Dimmesdale are the worst sinners, but Chillingworth seems to be more in the wrong here and even Dimmesdale, the Minster who committed a horrible crime, agrees. Of course he could be trying to protect Hester and himself by saying what Chillingworth is doing is worse, but torturing someone for your own sick, twisted gratification is pure evil.

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Quote #4

In chapter 13 of The Scarlet Letter the narrator talks about hoe Hester feels and acts years after she committed her crime. By now Pearl is seven years old and Hester has completely changed. She is no more a tender passionate woman; she could have possibly been burned by the brand of the “A” on her bosom. The townspeople also act differently towards Hester. They don’t usually notice her symbol anymore. They think of her symbol to mean “Able” instead of “Adultery.” On page 133, it states that when a stranger would ask who Hester was and why she was wearing such a strange badge the townspeople would reply by saying, “It is our Hester – the town’s Hester, - who is so kind to the poor, so helpful to the sick, so comfortable to the afflicted!” After so many years of dealing with one of their society members breaking the law, the townspeople pretty much forgot about her sin and think of Hester as a good, willing person.

If the society was going to end up thinking good of Hester why did they make such a big deal about her crime in the first place? This quote shows that the townspeople think they know everything but really don’t. If Hester could commit such a crime then be forgiven for it, what about all the other people they have killed for committing the same crime? This quote shows how bias the townspeople really are. Hester is actually a good person and now that her crime is in the past the townspeople can see that. If only they had looked past her mistake years earlier a lot of pain and time would have been saved.

Monday, April 26, 2010

Quote #3

In chapter 12 of The Scarlet Letter, Pearl and her mother, Hester, were talking to Mr. Dimmesdale. Pearl is consistently asking Dimmesdale to stand in public with her and her mother but he keeps turning her down saying he will at a later time. While they are all three standing together the narrator says, “There is witchcraft in little Pearl’s eyes; and her face, as she glanced upward at the minister, wore that naughty smile which made its expression frequently so elfish.” Most of the townspeople think Pearl is some kind of evil and this quote would support that. However, she was born into an unfortunate situation where nothing is her fault, so she has every right to act the way she does.

This quote explains how Pearl doesn’t just act like she has a demon in her; she also just looks like she has a demon in her. The townspeople already thought Pearl acted strange and now, as said by this quote, she even looks different and evil. This quote explains some of Pearl’s character. In reality, Pearl is a lot like her mother. She is different and has known that from the beginning just like Hester.

The way the narrator describes Pearl, especially in this quote, you could only think of her as pure evil. On the other hand, how could she be evil? She is only a little girl that was born into a bad situation that isn’t her fault. She never does anything that hurts anyone or does anything that could potentially harm someone. She has to cope with her problems some how and acting the way she does helps her go on with life and there’s nothing wrong with that. Pearl never did anything wrong and this quote is sort of misleading and makes the reader think badly about Pearl even though she is innocent.

Saturday, April 10, 2010

Quote #2

On page 68 of The Scarlet Letter Reverend Mr. Wilson is trying to get Hester to reveal the father of her child. She refuses no matter what he says. Then Hester tells the Reverend, “And my child must seek a heavenly Father; she shall never know an earthly one!” Hester does not want her daughter to know who her father is at all. This shows Hester has immense shame for her crime. She never wants to tell who the father is or even let her daughter know her own father.

This quote shows just how ashamed Hester is of her crime. She knows her daughter is a child of sin and that kills her inside. If she doesn’t even want her child to know her own father then there’s no way she is ever going to tell the townspeople who the father is. This quote also shows that Hester wants to take all the blame of the crime even though it wasn’t all her fault. She doesn’t want anyone else to be held responsible and that shows great strength and generosity.

This quote is significant because, again, it shows insight into Hester as a person. It illustrates her qualities and how she feels about her crime. Even though she committed a horrible crime, Hester is not a bad person. She’s a good person for not ratting out the father of her baby. She is the one who is going to be enduring all of the punishments, but if she told whom the father is he would too have to go through the penalties. This quote also shows that she cares for her baby no matter what. She wants to do what’s best for her and not letting her know the father is what she thinks is best. This quote gives the reader an idea about Hester, which could help while reading the book later.

Quote #1

On page 78 of The Scarlet Letter, the narrator is talking about Hester and makes a point that shows a lot about Hester even before her crime. The narrator states, “In all her intercourse with society, however, there was nothing that made her feel as if she belonged to it.” This quote speaks a great deal about how Hester was before she committed adultery. She never fully fit in anywhere with anyone; she has always seemed a little different from everyone else. And after she committed the crime, she became even more dissimilar from everyone else in society.

This quote is explaining that even before most society disowned her, she still didn’t fit in with them. She was always different and knew it. After this sentence on page 78, the narrator goes on to explain that every word, gesture, and even the silence with the people she came in contact with implied and expressed that she was alone as if she “inhabited another sphere.” She never felt fully connected with people in society and her crime just made that feeling worse.

This quote is very significant because it shows insight into Hester before the crime. The start of this book is all about the crime and how Hester is after it. The reader gets no information on how Hester acted or was seen before all of this happened, but this quote tells a lot about Hester as a person. It gives the reader an idea of what Hester was like before her offense and how people treated her then. After reading this, it seems as if society didn’t even accept Hester before the adultery because she was just a little different from them. Now, since she committed a horrible sin, they have an actual reason to not accept her.

Friday, April 9, 2010

The Status and Role of Women

The section in The Scarlet Letter on pages 246-253 was very interesting and made me think a lot about the differences between women today and women back then. A lot of the opinions in this reading really disgusted me. Most of the people who talked about women in this section believed they were below men and shouldn’t be treated the same. Many said that women shouldn’t have the right to do the same things a man does such as vote, have a job, etc. Men and women are both human beings, so not being treated equally really doesn’t make sense to me.

The first thing I though about while reading this is how much as changed regarding women from the 1600s to today. Women still complain and get mad over how they are not treated fairly, but if they knew just how bad women were treated back then, they wouldn’t have anything to grumble about. William Blackstone stated, “By marriage, the husband and wife are one person in law: that is, the very being or legal existence of the woman is suspended during the marriage… “ Today, women who are married can make their own decisions and are independent from their husbands. Likewise, today men who are married do not have to “give his wife moderate correction,” as said by William Blackstone. The whole outlook on women and even marriages has changed so much from back then and it was definitely for the better.

Even though most of the people in this passage had bias opinions about women, Catharine Beecher brought up a very fascinating point that I have never even considered before. She said, “women are always treated as superiors.” She goes on to explain that, basically, women had a lot of things handed to them that men didn’t. Women were not expected to go out and work a hard job or perform strenuous physical labor; they got to stay at home and do the less demanding tasks. Also, men would hold doors for women, carry things for them, stand when a lady entered the room, etc. This idea definitely makes sense, but women didn’t have to treated this way. I’m sure a lot of them would have liked to work a job if they were allowed. In addition, men didn’t have to those things for women. Of course it’s courteous, but women were capable to do all of those of their own.

In conclusion, the views on women have changed immensely over the years. Now women can actually have a say in most things. They can have jobs alongside men and don’t have to stay at home all the time. It is somewhat understandable as to why people thought women were so delicate and needed taken care of, but they took it to the extreme. Women are plenty capable of doing most things men are and can function perfectly without the cover or protection of a man.

Thursday, April 8, 2010

Adultery

On pages 241-245 of the book The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne, there are multiple laws describing the punishments of adultery and fornication in the 1600s. These punishments ranged from severe beatings to death. Sometimes the court even ordered that whoever commits adultery has to wear the letters A D stitched into their garments all day every day so everyone knows what they did. Ultimately, the laws explain that when someone commits adultery or fornication the punishments for he/she are usually debated and can be different for every person.

While reading, it puzzled me as to why back then they made adultery such a known thing around a community. I think when someone commits adultery it’s their own business and everyone else around shouldn’t know about it. Of course, adultery isn’t a morally good thing and no one should do it, but killing someone over it seems a little melodramatic. It seems back then they believed very strongly in morals. They didn’t want anyone to do anything that would seem even remotely sinful. Today a lot of people still have morals such as these, but they are not as drastic. It is amazing just how much ethics, beliefs, etc. have changed from back in the 1600s to today.

One sentence that really got me thinking was, “Cobbett advises men that the most important quality to look for in a wife is chastity…that made adultery a greater crime for women then for men.” I don’t understand why only the women were expected to be chaste. I’m sure the women wouldn’t have wanted to marry a man that was impure, so why did they have to? Also, I don’t understand why adultery was worse for women. That seems very sexist and unfair. A women committing adultery to a man or a man committing adultery to a woman; it’s the same thing so it doesn’t make sense that it should be greater for women. Although this way of treating women makes no sense, it all leads back to how much has really changed from back then.